Topic 5: Pros & Cons of OER – Content Producer’s P.O.V

online education concept

(Image from: Online Learning Tips)

This topic requires us to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of offering free accessible content in the eyes of a content producer. However, I’m pretty sure most of us interpreted the question as: Should online content be free, or not? It is in the nature of this topic to spur discussions on price and could easily be the sole focus. But I believe ‘online content’ goes deeper than monetary talks.

Advantages
(in offering free online content)

There are numerous established online learning platforms that offer free courses and materials, one of which is Skill Share. To date, Skill Share has over 1 Million Students with 500,00 projects and classes taught by 1,000 teachers. And the numbers are growing. As Skillshare, alongside other OER platforms, are a rather informal education system, content producers/teachers need not worry about having the right qualifications or the fitting image of a ‘teacher’ to conduct a class. This means that more career opportunities are opening up in the teaching industry.

The digital world exists without a physical form and it’s where information, once posted, are retained on the net almost forever. This gives the content producer long exposure time for their content and as the internet connects people across geographical boundaries, the producer is able to reach a much larger audience. Case in point would be Mary-Kate McDevitt whose first class on SkillShare has 28,000 students enrolled and the nationalities of her students extend beyond USA. This interconnectivity also allows for unrestricted learning where users, or students, can share information and opinions to any corner of the world.

The nature of the digital world allows for unrestricted communication and flexibility. Furthermore, by producing OER, it will be a good experience for content producers who are just beginning to start out.

Disadvantages

As OER uses internet and technology as a medium, it would be difficult to reach into areas with insufficient technology and content will be restricted. One main concern about OER’s is that they are not yet widely understood and accepted by the public, as they still believe in traditional learning – at school. This lack of understanding may spur several legal issues as the public are not used to or unaware of the copyright and licensing issues. This would also raise doubts about the credibility of information and producers may face restrictions in career advancement.

Therefore, with these problems in place, sustainability of sites offering OER is a long-term concern. Content producers should carefully select the safest and well-established platform to produce content for so that their works will not be re-used illegally and unethically.

Now comes the pressing problem: Should online content be free? If these content are free, then what do the producers earn? In my opinion, we should not be restricted to choose within “free” or “pay for physically non-existent content”. I think it would be right if some content requires us to pay, because it’s still a person’s hard work and knowledge. But it is crucial to keep the price low so that individuals can slowly accept the idea. With the advancement of technology and increasing reliance on technology, it has changed how we live and how businesses earn, and it is time to accept this new digital education system.

References:

How Teaching 50,000 Students Changed Mary Kate McDevitt’s Life

7 Things you should know about Open Educational Resources

The Pros and Cons of Open Educational Resources

Become a Skillshare teacher

7 Tips for Young and Young-at-Heart Content Producers

Dramatically Bringing down the cost of education with OER

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Topic 5: Pros & Cons of OER – Content Producer’s P.O.V

  1. Pingback: We need to be heard! | Amanda's

  2. Hi Sze Li,

    Thanks for recommending Skill Share! I googled it and found it really interesting that they offer courses like photography, design and fashion. Those are my area of interest and I can’t believe they are free! Will definitely check them out soon!

    I do agree with you on how OER is not yet widely understood and accepted by the public because of technology and content restrictions. It is a shame how most institutions still choose to use traditional textbooks when OER is more educationally effective and less expensive. Based on my own experience, I often have to stop myself from using the highlighter to make markings in textbooks so I can later pass it to other students or sell them online. With OER, I believe I will be able to engage them through active study processes like highlighting and annotating.

    However, I am not totally against on the idea of paid access either. Like you mentioned, ‘I think it would be right if some content requires us to pay, because it’s still a person’s hard work and knowledge’. I share the same sentiments on that and support the idea of low subscription fees to slowly draw more users.

    Anyway your post is also very clear and concise, loved reading it!

    Regards,
    Vanna

    Like

  3. Pingback: Yes to open access! | vanna

  4. YS

    Hi Sze Li,
    Thank you for sharing Skillshare! I thought it was clever of Skillshare to employ the idea of crowdsourcing in gathering ideas onto a common platform. As you mentioned, one of the pressing concern of open access information was the management of adequate pricing that needs to be affordable to the online audience and yet at the same time, ensuring that the content producer is rewarded sufficiently.

    If we look at the case of Skillshare, do you think that use of a “freemium” model will alleviate the issue? From what I see, users may opt for free membership that allows access to certain lessons whereas a premium user has privileges such as support online teachers and offline access to videos. The link (http://help.skillshare.com/hc/en-us/articles/205222327-How-can-I-earn-money-on-Skillshare-) tells how an individual can gain revenue from Skillshare! Simply put, Skillshare uses the frees gained from premium users to cover all costs, inculding maintenance of free membership and contributors’ royalities. Like what you said it’s time to accept a digital education system, how about a change in our business models? Do you think users are just looking at the value of product or simply more than that (i.e. the service)?

    Cheers.

    Like

  5. Pingback: The evolving needs (Topic 5) | YISHIN

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s